
If you study the plotting of the books, if you pay attention to the themes and ideas Rowling tries to convey, you'll see that Snape can't possibly be a bad guy. But even knowing this, the reveal was surprising.
There are spoilers in this post, but if you haven’t read Harry Potter by now, well—what’s wrong with you?
We’re less than three weeks away from the final installment of the Harry Potter movies: Deathly Hallows Part II hits theaters at midnight on July 15. I’ve already got my tickets for the midnight double header (Parts I and II), and I’ve gotten over my sadness that the Lansing-area does not have an all-day marathon like Grand Rapids, does (yes, I would have gotten up at 4:30 a.m. to watch all eight movies, I know that makes me a bit of a fangirl).
I started reading Harry Potter at about fifteen. My sister had the first two books, and I made fun of her for reading kid literature (never mind that she was a kid). My dad read books one and two to my sister, but since she was in the room next door, I eventually started listening in. Then, when the third book came out (we only had one copy of each book, at that point) I read it straight through one night because I knew I had to give it back to my sister in the morning. Book four we read aloud as a family then listened to on audio book in the car on the way to one of my soccer tournaments (24 hours in a car is not enough to listen to Goblet of Fire, by the way). The fifth book came out during a family reunion in Alabama, and there were no bookstores in a 50-mile radius. I waited in line at Walmart at 6:30 a.m. then promptly ignored my relatives for the remainder of the trip. (As a funny aside, this place was so hick that Walmart had only stocked a few copies, and the employees were surprised that they were over halfway sold out ten minutes after they opened. My family bought four copies. We don’t like to share.) The sixth book I bought at midnight the day before work selling Sunglasses, a day, I admit, that I wasn’t all that on the ball, because I’d been up until almost 7 a.m., repeatedly telling myself, “just one more chapter.” The seventh book I read over three days, because I didn’t want to admit it was all over.
My generation, my sister’s generation—we’re in an interesting spot. We grew up with the madness (even if some of us were just a touch older). It was the book that started midnight release events for books rather than relegating them to just movies. It was the book that got an entire generation to read, to love reading. But these are the things we all know about Harry Potter. These are the things in every news story.
Ever since I stayed up all night reading Prisoner of Azkaban ten-plus years ago, I’ve been waiting for the next piece to come. First it was the books, then the movies. And now even those are ending. I’ve always liked the suspense of waiting, of wondering what’s going to happen. This has become especially true since I started writing. The more I learned about stories, about plot and characters, about language, the more I was able to analyze the books, to critique, or guess what was coming next. I was too young, too inexperienced, when the fifth book came out to understand that Sirius needed to die, to get that heroes need to lose their mentors to be able to stand on their own. I don’t remember how I felt about Dumbledore’s death the next book, but that very fact makes me sure that it came as less of a surprise. By the time the seventh book came out, I had seen that big character twist coming. Snape, I’d argued for two years, had to be good. All evidence aside, the structure of Rowling’s world, the messages she was trying to convey, meant that he couldn’t possibly be bad. Otherwise the world really was black and white. (Also, I knew a Weasley had to go, by sheer odds).
I won’t argue that Harry Potter is some great work of literature on the language level. It was never supposed to be. Her writing does seem to reflect the fact that the books moved beyond children’s literature in the later books, but there is just as much of an argument that she simply got better through practice as there is that she upped her game for her adult audience (more, even, in my opinion). Yeah, some things are annoying (for instance, Rowling loves for Hermione to say things “waspishly,” usually to Ron, and if you can’t hear that tone in her voice without the adjective, you haven’t been paying attention). But there are other things she does well, even if they are heavy handed, if compared to adult literature. The scene in the seventh book where Ron walks out on Harry and Hermione is especially well done (so much so, in fact, that the movie version of it felt very flat to me), and it was the first time that I really noticed, as a writer, that you can accomplish a lot of things by having the characters’ surroundings reflect the mood you’re going for. (Also, the plotting is nothing short of astounding. I have nothing but respect for people who put together series where each book builds on the previous; I can hardly hold the form of a story in the palm of my hands.)
I’ve always been a firm believer that you can learn from any type of writing, good or bad, genre or literature (though this distinction makes me uncomfortable), for children or adults. Harry Potter has confirmed this to me. Whether you love or hate the books (or don’t really care), you can’t deny that there is something magical in the stories (pun totally intended). Anything that inspires such a multitude of readers deserves to be studied for that fact, if nothing else. (As an aside, I hate to make that argument, because it means that I will probably end up reading Twilight someday, no matter how that hurts me inside. But it’s still true.)
Is anyone else a Potter fan? Is anyone else doing anything special in preparation for the final movie? If, like me, you feel both excited and sad about the end, just remember, there’s still more coming.